Sep 29

Top New York Universities: Columbia or NYU?

Top New York Universities: Columbia or NYU?

Two of the top institutions in New York City are Columbia University and New York University (NYU). Both have good rankings in the QS World University Rankings: USA 2021.

Which one is best for you? 

New York City, one of the most well-known cities in the world and a major center for commerce and culture, is also a significant hub for higher learning. More than 100 universities and colleges serve more than 500,000 students in NYC, and impressively, 13 of them are listed in the most recent QS World University Rankings: USA 2021.

Two institutions in New York stand out from the rest of the pack among this dizzying assortment of choices: Columbia University and New York University (NYU). In the 2021 USA rankings, these two New York City institutions are rated seventh and ninth respectively. They also appear in the top 10 in a number of the 51 fields listed in the QS World University Rankings by Subject.

Between them, these two universities have produced a who’s who of well-known alumni, including writers (Allen Ginsberg, Jack Kerouac), politicians (Barack Obama), business moguls (Warren Buffet), musicians (Lauren Hill), film directors (Martin Scorsese, Woody Allen), and fashion designers (Tom Ford).

Do you want to emulate their actions? Let’s examine each university’s advantages in more detail.

Do you want to improve your chances of getting into a top-tier university? Schedule your consultation with Tokyo Academics today!

Choose between New York City’s two best institutions

The Ivy League is made up of the two universities with the most illustrious academic reputations in America, Columbia University and Harvard University. But NYU has its own personality and charm, far from being overshadowed by its competition.

NYU is a top-tier university with locations all over the fashionable downtown of New York City and one of the most dynamic environments in the world for the arts, music, and culture. Columbia places students in the relative solitude of an Ivy League campus environment, whereas NYU placed them in the center of the metropolis. The university, which is proudly based in artistic Greenwich Village and has neither walls nor gates, is “in and of the city.”

Admission to either university is exceedingly competitive, as one might anticipate from internationally recognized colleges in such a coveted area. Few applicants will be chosen by either, much less both, but if you have strong academic credentials and are seeking the most exciting study abroad opportunity the US has to offer, there is a good chance that at least one of these two prestigious universities in New York City will be on your shortlist.

Here’s a comparison of them so you can decide which could be better suitable for you.

Columbia
NYU
  • Ranked seventh in the USA. 
  • Ranked sixth in the USA for research impact  
  • Joint seventh for learning experience 
  • Joint 44th for diversity and internationalisation 
  • Sixth for employability 
  • Ranked ninth in the USA, 13th for research impact  
  • Joint 22nd for learning experience  
  • Joint first for diversity and internationalisation 
  • 10th for employability.

Subject strengths, based on the broad subject areas in the QS World University Rankings by Subject 2021

  • Ranked 10th in the world for arts & humanities 
  • 10th in the world for English language and literature 
  • 10th for earth and marine sciences  
  • 10th for social policy and administration  
  • Joint 10th for geology
  • Ranked first in the world for philosophy 
  • 10th in the world for accounting and finance 
  • 12th for mathematics 
  • 12th for economics and econometrics 
  • 12th for social sciences and management 
  • 13th for psychology

Location

Central campus located on the upper west side of Manhattan.

Six different locations in Manhattan, with a satellite campus in Abu Dhabi

Central campus is in Greenwich Village, lower Manhattan.

Student community

Approx. 31,455 students enrolled (as of autumn 2020

8,842 undergraduates; 18,272 graduate students; 4068 on continuing education/special programs 

International students: 36 percent of total

Approx. 58,461 students enrolled (as of 2019

26,981 undergraduates; 25,904 graduate and professional students; 5,576 on non-credit programs 

International students: 24 percent of total

USA 2021 QS World University Rankings

The United States’ seventh-ranked nation this year, Columbia has consistently remained towards the top of the global rankings for the previous ten years. It does well across all metrics, narrowly defeating NYU in three areas: the influence of research, the learning process, and employability.

These findings show that academics from a wide range of disciplines rank Columbia among the best colleges in the world in their respective fields, and companies from all over the world think it produces some of the most marketable graduates.

Even though it lags a little, NYU has developed a solid reputation as a top-notch institution. It comes in first in the diversity and internationalization indices and is ranked ninth overall in the USA.

The indicator measuring learning experience is where there is the most difference between the two. Columbia asserts a sizable lead in this situation. In the USA, it is ranked eighth, tied with NYU for 22nd.

 

Subject Advantages

The performance of these two universities in the most recent QS World University Rankings by Subject should also be taken into account while evaluating them. A brief check at the 2019 tables reveals that both of New York’s top institutions are best-known for their work in the humanities, social sciences, and arts, and they both rank in the top 10 globally in a number of fields.

In truth, NYU claims to have the top philosophy program, with its next best rankings in the performing arts (sixth), communications and media studies (seventh), law (eighth), and mathematics (12th). Anatomy and physiology, which is ranked fourth at Columbia, is followed by history, law, earth and marine sciences, and English literature and language (both in 10th).

In several social science fields, like economics and law, the two are roughly on par, as the table below demonstrates. Other times, one or the other clearly dominates; for example, Columbia scores far higher in physics while NYU is more impressive in the performing arts.

Columbia and NYU in the QS World University Rankings by Subject 2019
Columbia
NYU

Accounting & finance

12th

10th

Anatomy & physiology

4th

Anthropology

12th

17th

Architecture

Joint 14th

101-150

Art & design

Joint 41st

45th

Biological sciences

19th

44th

Business & management

19th

17th

Chemistry

Joint 42nd

201-250

Classics & ancient history

50th

Communication & media studies

Joint 18th

7th

Computer science

18th

21st

Dentistry

Joint 41st

17th

Development studies

16th

Earth & marine sciences

10th

Economics

11th

12th

Education

11th

Joint 41st

Engineering (chemical)

53rd

251-300

Engineering (civil)

51-100

Engineering (electrical)

Joint 49th

78th

Engineering (mechanical)

Joint 87th 

151-200

English language & literature

10th

15th

Environmental sciences

33rd

251-300

Geology

Joint 10th

Geophysics

11th

History

6th

Joint 30th

Hospitality & leisure management

51-100

Law

7th

8th

Linguistics

Joint 97th

40th

Materials science

Joint 75th 

Mathematics

16th

12th

Medicine

13th

Joint 33rd

Modern languages

11th

17th

Nursing

Joint 18th

24th

Performing arts

Joint 22nd

6th

Pharmacy

Joint 47th

Joint 82nd

Philosophy

25th

1st

Physics & astronomy

Joint 18th

Join 108th

Politics & international studies

13th

Joint 14th

Psychology

12th

13th

Social policy & administration

10th

46th

Sociology

15th

16th

Statistics

Joint 11th

51-100

Theology, divinity & religious studies

40th

101-120

Location

Considering grand quadrangles, neoclassical columns, and well kept lawns, one could say that Columbia offers the perfect Ivy League campus atmosphere.

But unlike other Ivy League schools like Princeton or Yale, Columbia is a tranquil oasis in the center of a busy city. Despite being on Manhattan’s upper western point, it is nonetheless conveniently close to the action.

One of the city’s most vibrant and diverse neighborhoods lies nearby, called Harlem. The Hudson River and Central Park are also nearby, providing some gorgeous relief from New York’s infamous urban jungle.

While Columbia will for many students provide the ideal balance of academic solitude and close proximity to the action, NYU offers a more immersive urban experience. Despite having campuses all throughout the city, the university’s main campus is in Greenwich Village, right in the center of the city’s cultural and social life.

There are no fences or gates separating NYU’s Washington Square campus from the nearby streets’ abundance of eateries, pubs, and cafés. When you study here, you can anticipate being in the heart of one of the world’s most culturally vibrant regions.

With a score of seven in the student view indicator, which is based on a survey asking students to rate their city on factors such as affordability, ease of getting around, employment opportunities, arts and culture, and more, New York consistently ranks among the top 20 of the QS Best Student Cities ranking.

 

Student Population

When professional courses are taken into account, NYU has a far larger overall student body than Columbia.

Although both are at the larger end of the scale and offer sizable and diverse student populations, Columbia has a more diversified student body than NYU (Columbia places 63rd in the world for its percentage of international students whereas NYU ranks 94th).

Columbia is more strongly focused on graduate studies, with graduates outnumbering undergraduates by a two to one ratio, as befits its standing as a research-intensive university. In contrast, NYU has more undergraduates than Columbia by more than three times, with a higher proportion of undergraduates than graduate students.

 

Finances and fees

Leading private universities in the US are well-known for being pricey, and neither of these two prestigious universities in New York is an exception. International students at both universities pay the same overall tuition as domestic students.

NYU’s annual undergraduate tuition fees for 2020–2021 total US$61,671, while Columbia’s rate for that same year was US$58,920 (including other required fees). At the graduate level, costs vary based on the graduate program and the subject, but master’s programs at both universities are probably going to start at roughly $50,000–52,000 per year.

At both institutions, most students use a combination of personal savings, loans, financial aid, and scholarships to cover the cost of their education. The majority of Columbia University students—50%—receive financial aid, with the average award amount being $52,073. Similar to this, a large number of NYU students receive financial aid.

Both institutions include net price calculators on their websites, which prospective students can use to estimate how much they would have to pay and what financial help they could be eligible for. These calculators are available at all US universities. You may find the net price calculator from NYU here, along with a complete list of funding possibilities. The net price calculator for Columbia can be found here, along with information on funding here.